The Toads Tacky Tastes

I was just listening to Book 5 on tape again. I was at the part where on the Friday evening Harry misses Keeper tryouts because of Umbridge's week long detention she touches his arm and his scar sears with pain. But what I was noticing was that just as this is happening, for the second time Rowling notes that Umbridge is wearing a load of gaudy rings. Now, maybe Sirius was right, maybe the pain had simply to do with some feeling Voldy is feeling intensely that is unconnected, and maybe all that is going on with Umbridge is bad taste. BUT, maybe (as Granger and we have speculated before) the scar is a horcrux, and what makes the scar hurt is a horcrux connection ... this is what I have speculated before concerning that Dumbledore suspects (and I think rightly) that the snake Nagini is a horcrux and my own observations that both dreams in book 4 involve the snake present (I think as a horcrux channel) and Harry sees the snake's attack through the eyes of the snake itself. And MAYBE one of those gaudy rings is more than simply a ring. It is merely speculation, but there are a number of coincidentals that should be considered. 1. The line that Sirius and Hermione and Ron use in discounting Umbridge involves her being consciously a death eater or carrying Voldy in her the way Quirrel did in book 1. But maybe Umbridge has the ring unwittingly - and I mean that with an utterly negative connotation ... Many who worship bureaucracy for bureaucracy's sake let themselves get connected with bad stuff out of an "the ends justify the means" mentality, hence her willingness to use the Cruciatus ... but maybe her "pure humanity" bigotry has made her think an heirloom from a "pure blood" bigot not such a bad thing to own. Thus it would not be Umbridge personally who is making the scar hurt but the ring horcrux. 2. Rowling mentions the gaudy rings at least twice, rather conspicuously. 3. In book 5 the connection with Voldy as pertains to the legilemency thing is more on the emotional level ... Harry's blood practically boils with anger/hatred when Dumbledore touches him, or he sees visions etc. The scar thing is still a unique and very distinct phenomenon, and one which cannot be explained by Umbridge and the coincidence is a pretty odd one you must admit, of how closely the two are connected - her touch with that hand full of rings, and his scar hurting. This is part of what makes me suspect so strongly that the scar is an horcrux and that the pain has to do with close proximity/connection to another horcrux and thus another piece of Voldy's soul. Iin book 1 this is obviously the horcrux of the "main part" of Voldemort's soul living on the back of Quirrel's head. I believe it is a riddle: how could Umbridge be carrying Voldemort the way Quirrel was? The answer is in book 6: a horcrux.