Muggle Matters Home
About our site
Make Site Suggestions
Narrative defined (Merlin)
Silver & Gold (Merlin)
Elendil's Sword (Pauli)
"X" Marks/Chiasm (Merlin)
Literary Approaches (Merlin)

Travis Prinzi




Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More

We hope you enjoy reading our Harry Potter discussion weblog. Please feel free to leave a comment and return often for more discussion.



 
 
View blog reactions
Add to Google
Add this blog to my Technorati Favorites!

Merlin guest posts on HogPro
Merlin Comment on Hog Pro Thread
Merlin finds Merlin: a Book Review/Plug
This blog has moved
Grindelwald the Elitist
Ghost-Town Gazette headline: Merlin Posts a commen...
You can't always get what you want, but sometimes ...
Hargid as the Rubedo
Griffyndor vs Slytherin: Bookends in books 1 and 7
Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Movie


----------------------------------------------------------------------- -->
06/01/2004 - 07/01/2004
08/01/2004 - 09/01/2004
09/01/2004 - 10/01/2004
10/01/2004 - 11/01/2004
11/01/2004 - 12/01/2004
01/01/2005 - 02/01/2005
03/01/2005 - 04/01/2005
07/01/2005 - 08/01/2005
08/01/2005 - 09/01/2005
09/01/2005 - 10/01/2005
10/01/2005 - 11/01/2005
11/01/2005 - 12/01/2005
12/01/2005 - 01/01/2006
01/01/2006 - 02/01/2006
02/01/2006 - 03/01/2006
03/01/2006 - 04/01/2006
04/01/2006 - 05/01/2006
05/01/2006 - 06/01/2006
06/01/2006 - 07/01/2006
07/01/2006 - 08/01/2006
08/01/2006 - 09/01/2006
09/01/2006 - 10/01/2006
10/01/2006 - 11/01/2006
11/01/2006 - 12/01/2006
12/01/2006 - 01/01/2007
01/01/2007 - 02/01/2007
02/01/2007 - 03/01/2007
03/01/2007 - 04/01/2007
04/01/2007 - 05/01/2007
05/01/2007 - 06/01/2007
06/01/2007 - 07/01/2007
07/01/2007 - 08/01/2007
08/01/2007 - 09/01/2007
09/01/2007 - 10/01/2007
10/01/2007 - 11/01/2007
11/01/2007 - 12/01/2007
12/01/2007 - 01/01/2008
01/01/2008 - 02/01/2008
04/01/2008 - 05/01/2008
11/01/2008 - 12/01/2008
07/01/2009 - 08/01/2009
08/01/2009 - 09/01/2009
02/01/2010 - 03/01/2010
04/01/2010 - 05/01/2010
06/01/2010 - 07/01/2010
12/01/2010 - 01/01/2011


Hogwarts, Hogwarts,
Hoggy Warty Hogwarts,
Teach us something please,
Whether we be old and bald,
Or young with scabby knees,
Our heads could do with filling,
With some interesting stuff,
For now they're bare
And full of air,
Dead flies and bits of fluff.
So teach us stuff worth knowing,
Bring back what we forgot,
Just do your best
We'll do the rest,
And learn until our brains all rot!



1: The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork.
2: Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge.
3: There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.
4: Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. In them hath he set a tabernacle for the sun,
5: Which is as a bridegroom coming out of his chamber, and rejoiceth as a strong man to run a race.
6: His going forth is from the end of the heaven, and his circuit unto the ends of it: and there is nothing hid from the heat thereof.
7: The law of the LORD is perfect, converting the soul: the testimony of the LORD is sure, making wise the simple.
8: The statutes of the LORD are right, rejoicing the heart: the commandment of the LORD is pure, enlightening the eyes.
9: The fear of the LORD is clean, enduring for ever: the judgments of the LORD are true and righteous altogether.
10: More to be desired are they than gold, yea, than much fine gold: sweeter also than honey and the honeycomb.
11: Moreover by them is thy servant warned: and in keeping of them there is great reward.
12: Who can understand his errors? cleanse thou me from secret faults.
13: Keep back thy servant also from presumptuous sins; let them not have dominion over me: then shall I be upright, and I shall be innocent from the great transgression.
14: Let the words of my mouth, and the meditation of my heart, be acceptable in thy sight, O LORD, my strength, and my redeemer.

Saturday, May 27, 2006

X-Men 3, Harry Potter and the Imago Dei

Well, X Men 3 hit the theaters and I went to see it. I was going to use the term "Crux-Men" in the title of this post for what I noticed as connections between Harry Potter and this most interesting third installment in the X-Men series (of which there may be more, but regardless this third one works as a good finale to a trilogy, with certain "bookend" elements recurring from the first movie, such as that the movie begins and ends with Magneto and both movies begin with a flashback to the discovery of a crucial mutant's powers ... what I mean is that even if they come out with more X-Men movies, I think these first three will always hang together as at least an introductory trilogy). But I thought using the regular title would better facilitate people finding this post via google searches.

Introduction: Comic Books and Fantasy Literature

I'll be honest, I have never liked the category of "fantasy literature." It seems to me like merely a marketing term that really completely misses what sets authors like Rowling, Tolkien, Lewis, William, Chesterton et al apart. They are not your average grasping at the pyrotechnical appeal of swords and sorcery ... the latter of which (in its true form, ie the truly dark, but hidden and disguised, hear of dark magic) seems to be a pet special fascination of some rather popular fantasy authors (meaning that the particular works I am thinking of seem to rely heavily on a flavor of psychic animism/dynamism in their material for their draw, and maybe someday I'll get around to writing exactly what I mean by that last term, but for here I'll just say that it is at the heart of what I would call "neo-paganism," which I believe to be worse than classical paganism, which at least had some concept of the transcendent, however weak or warped)

Along these lines, I am into a broader range of mediums and genres that share the symbolist outlook of the mythopoeic authors listed above, one such being film. Another is the comic book hero ... and here we find movies such as the X-Men trilogy, movies adapted from comic books. But another which greatly caught my attention in this regard was M. Night Shymalan's "Unbreakable."

Samuel L, Jackson's character (Elijah Price ... a prophet for the sake of profit? ironically like true insight hidden within a medium formatted for mass production and consumption?) makes the statement that he believes comic books to be the last remaining vestige of a more primal form of communicating the meaning believed to be in the world, a medium based more directly in the image.

I think Price is right about this (and I find it highly interesting that he is the villain) and that the X-Men series, now that I have seen this third installment, strongly supports this. Let me note first that if the reader is looking for evidence of the "conscious construction," any of my writing is not the place to look for it. I believe it entirely possible that such authors and movie makers consciously and methodically construct these elements into their works (and indeed I would find it highly odd if the recognition did not penetrate the consciously level to some degree or another) but I am not overly concerned when it might be the case that the authorial impetus for these elements lies in the subconscious rather than the conscious.

Horcruxing and the true villain
(WARNING: Contains spoiler material on the X-Men 3 movie)

Before I get into the material on imagination and the Imago Dei, however, let me relate the first thing in the movie that started me thinking about the similarities and developments between this movie and Harry Potter. This thing, however, is not "within the movie itself" in explicit terms but is rather only alluded to, in the body of the film itself, very slightly. Fortunately I saw it with a friend who had heard some scuttlebutt on the net and said "we have to stay through the credits, there's a tagged-on thing that's supposed to be really interesting."

So ... we sat through the credits, and there it was ... the very thing Xavier had been putting to his mutant ethics class as a question, he simply went and did - he telepathically communicates with the woman colleague who is taking care of the vegetave, "consciousless" man ... indicating he had done what he had spoken of. Somehow that odd look on his face when phoenix has him suspended in the air just before he "dies," that look that you cannot tell whether it is simply a grimace from the sheer physio-psychic force, or whether it is an oddly evil and menacing smile towards Wolverine - very well may be the latter.

I immediately thought of Xavier's transplanting or migrating of his conscious/mind/soul into the vegetative man as aligned with Voldemort's favorite "life-saver" - his horcruxes. Xavier puts his soul into a body it was not originally united to, in a sense he "cruxes" or "crosses" two things that were not meant to be together - his soul was meant to be with his body.

Some might think that this puts Charles Xavier in a pretty dim light, so I'll just come right out and say it: I think he is the true villain of the whole trilogy. You find as much in Logan/Wolverine's reaction at being told what Xavier had originally done to Grey - forced the control of her powers. Here we see a much uglier side of Xavier: "I don't need to explain myself ... least of all to you." (emphasis added). The better path would have been formation through personal relationship and simply, to echo Dumbledore, the amazing power of love.

This is an "under the surface" but very strong theme in this movie. It is basically the element of volitional negation, the ability to say no to a certain action or course of action, use of power etc. Rogue chooses to extremely suppress her powers (I think the last scene with magneto shows that the cure does not work permanently, one cannot simply eradicate imagination, but in certain circumstances and situations, for the higher good, one can practice mortification of it) in order to be with Bobby in the human form of tactile contact. Part of the rightness in her case lies in the particular nature of her power: women are naturally more empathetic than men, but Rogue's level of empathy reaches a level where the actual life force is drained. The point in the movie is that she has the right to make that choice to sublimate that particular power so that her empathy can remain at a natural level and, by movie's end, she can complete male-female pairing with him.

Free Will

This is ability to say "no" is symbolized most strongly in the boy mutant whose genes provide the "cure." He is a true mutant, truly supra-physical power, but one that symbolizes the ability, in free will, to say no - and this mutant power deserves to live the same as Magneto's and others' (and I loved Kitty Pride's exercise of cunning in adapting to taking on a massive villain without her powers when protecting the boy - naturally, if she's close enough to protect the boy, her powers don't work, but neither do Jughead's. )

The nature of Xavier's denial of the importance of free will, as contra-Dumbledore (note that in the traditional Augustinian "psychological model of the Trinity" the precise and most basic function of the will, is to love), strikes me in a particular instance in Rowling's latest installment (which I have listened to twice recently) - Dumbledore (contra-Xavier) tells Harry that to coerce Slughorn by magic to share the memory, simply will not work, and in the end Felix Felicis simply helps Harry set the stage. Once the alcohol has helped Sluggo drop his defenses so that he will actually listen to what Harry is saying (rather than what Harry is saying falling on "deaf ears" that are effectually deafened by the wall of clamorously defensive arguments Sluggo has built up in his own mind - ie, the alcohol simply helps Harry actually be heard out), it is Harry's honest arguments (sans magic) that do the positive convincing, and Sluggo gives the memory freely, of his own volition (just because he will not remember it in the morning does mean he does not act rightly fully of his own accord).

Natural and Supernatural

In the end there is a question that neither X-Men nor Harry Potter ask on the material level, but rather leave open, and that is the question the supernatural, or Grace. For such moral formation and support (vs mutant-power forcing, psychic manipulation by Xavier) to work in the case of Jean Gray (and indeed for any and all of us, since we all possess the power of imagination and thus the power to abuse it) would take Grace.

Since what Grace facilitates (the material characteristics of moral action) is precisely what the symbols or a morality tale are representing, any unique or "allegorical" representation of Grace appears more like a Deus Ex Machina (although there can be great and lesser "hints" of a presence or power coming into the story from above its actual scope, and I would say the Harry Potter series definitely has a stronger such presence in it, with elements such as Buckbeak, but I must say I did love the Angel character in X3, especially the swooping save of his father). This is simply the way morality tales work.

Imagination

After noticing the Horcrux connection I began thinking about the movie along the lines of what I have thought about Harry Potter, particularly along the lines of seeing the imagination as the fore-runner for Rowling's "magic" ("fore-runner" meaning I think her "magic" has many facets and correpsondances at different level, that it has a multi-faceted and multi-valent breadth and depth to it, but I think the single actual supra-physical power that it corresponds to is the imagination ... "supra-physical" meaning it is above and beyond the physical - if I am big and beafy I can pick you up and move you from one place to another by brute physical force, and I might even be able get you to do certain things by threatening to kill you, by threat of physical violence, but to motivate you do these things without such physical coercions, that takes powers above and beyond the more purely physical)

Now, I have been tossing this around a lot, like simply because I postulated that "magic" in Harry Potter and "mutant powers" represent the imagination, that makes it so. So, here is the "evidence" portion. Scott/Cyclops is vision (the power of the eyes) and it is he who resurrects Jean/Phoenix from the watery grave. But then what happens? Imagination (Phoenix) perverted by controlling powers, rather than habituated properly through love - unbridled imagination, without guidance of truth habituated by love in interpersonal relationship (a fancy way of saying "family") ... kills vision.

Of course, the discussion thus far does not examine the matter of Logan/Wolverine ... which is a pretty important one since he is the second love of Jean Grey, and instead of her killing him like she kills cyclops, he kills her. I'm not saying I have it all put together yet, not by a long shot, but I think it has something to do with the fact that Logan represents some new, deeper manifestation of humanity than Scott does and Jean makes a fatal mistake in movie 2 in choosing Scott over Logan. Maybe Grey, as imagination, should have progressed beyond her love of the eyes to whatever is more fundamentally human (as defined by the Incarnation - which brings healing and regeneration, like Wolverines power)

The Imago Dei

You may be disappointed here by the lack of verbiage (especially given my verbosity throughout this piece) but the reason is ... it is a mystery - one of the deepest. The power of imagination is so crucial and critical because, somehow, in some very deep way, it flows from the fact that humanity is made Imago Dei - in the image of God. In some mystical way, the power of the imagination is the subjective disposition that mirrors the objective characteristic of being made in God's image. I think that in both Harry Potter and X-Men you see a lot of instances that hint at this, glimpses of a deep and profound truth about the uniqueness of human dignity and the distinct powers of humanity, particularly the ability to see not only with the physical eyes but with the eyes of the mind and heart, in fact able to see higher truths with them ... which is basically what the fore-going ramble has been, an attempt to help to see those glimpses.

Post-Script
Just an afterthought ... Kelsey Grammer is great as beast. The whole logic of why he was such a good choice is evident in one line: in the final battle scene Wolverine says, " I thought you were a diplomat" and beast replies "well, all men reach a point where ... well, you get the point!" in a very Frasier Crane way. (But I really missed nightcrawler - great character)
posted by Merlin at 7:50 PM
3 comments


Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Harry is Kosher!

Hat tip to La Shawn for this great bit from Kesher Talk. It made me think about Merlin's post comparing Gandalf, Moses and Dumbledore which was well worth a second visit (or third?).
posted by Pauli at 8:30 AM
0 comments


Tuesday, May 23, 2006

A case of art inspiring science

From the Times Online:

"The 66 million-year-old dragon-like monster has been given the title Dracorex hogwartsia because it resembles the kind of fantastical creature encountered by the teenage wizard."
Read the whole article.

Here's one with a picture courtesy USA Today.
posted by Pauli at 9:41 PM
0 comments


Friday, May 12, 2006

Concursus Dei?

I'm throwing this one at the rim hoping for a Merlin theological rebound. Divine concurrency is defined as a doctrine that God can decree human choices without men losing responsibility. I was wondering if the sorting hat's decrees might be analogous to this. Here's a passage from Philosopher's Stone, Harry is talking to Neville:

"You're worth twelve of Malfoy," Harry said. "The sorting hat chose you for Gryffindor, didn't it? And where's Malfoy? In stinking Slytherin."

In the next book, Harry is wondering whether the sorting hat made a mistake in placing him in Gryffindor. After all, it did "try" to put him in Slytherin at first. Dumbledore assures him that pulling Gryffindor's sword out of the hat was confirmation that the hat had made the correct choice. In a sense, it was Harry's choice to turn from the evil which he knew existed Slytherin and the hat's response to put him into Gryffindor.

But was the hat's mention of Slytherin a sort of test or temptation? Draco Malfoy didn't need to be tempted - it seemed like he got exactly what he wanted which was to be in Slytherin. So in a sense the temptation elicited the strong response given by Harry, but without forcing Harry's will or making the decision without his input. The hat is of course not divine, but does appear to have the ability to "see" into the mind of the wearer.
posted by Pauli at 6:50 PM
0 comments


Wednesday, May 10, 2006

Somewhere a Dog Barked ...

Man, been awful quiet around here these days ... just dropping in to say hello in the echoes.

Today was 11 hours editing in the office and now going to be another 2-3 hours editing here ... all the days have been like that recently and looks like they will be for a bit yet if the project I'm on is going to get done.

Just wanted to throw up a post to say hello to any regular readers who have been popping around and wondering where we have floated off to (and don't worry, I didn't have to eat a puking pastil to throw it up either LOL)
posted by Merlin at 10:20 PM
2 comments






Blog Directory & Search engine

Syndicate Muggle Matters (XML feed)
iPing-it!